5 Best Golf Balls for Mid Handicappers (2024 Reviews)

How I Tested & Rank Golf Balls

Measure Distance

When it comes to measuring distance, I took each ball out for a spin on the driving range, keeping my swing speed consistent to see how far each one would fly. 

The Vice Pro Plus really stood out here, offering impressive distance without sacrificing control.

But don’t overlook the TaylorMade Tour Response—it’s designed for those of you with higher swing speeds who want to squeeze every last yard out of your drives. 

I always say, distance is great, but it’s even better when you know you can rely on it round after round.

Accuracy

Accuracy is key for mid-handicappers trying to lower their scores, so I paid close attention to how each ball performed when it came to keeping shots on line. 

The Srixon Q Star was a strong performer, consistently hitting fairways and greens, which is crucial when you’re trying to avoid those costly misses. 

Meanwhile, the Kirkland Urethane 3 Piece was surprisingly reliable, especially considering its price.

I’ve seen firsthand how a ball that stays true to its line can make a huge difference in your confidence and score.

Spin Rate

Spin rate can make or break your short game, so I spent a lot of time testing how these balls reacted on approach shots and around the greens. 

The Vice Pro Plus offers just the right amount of spin, allowing you to stop the ball quickly on the greens. 

On the other hand, the Callaway Supersoft provides a bit less spin, which can be beneficial if you’re prone to over-spinning the ball. 

I’ve noticed that finding the right spin rate is crucial for mid-handicappers as it helps in controlling those all-important approach shots.

Price

Let’s be real—price matters. I tested these balls with an eye on value, because getting the most bang for your buck is always a good thing.

The Kirkland Urethane 3 Piece is a standout budget option here, delivering premium performance without the premium price tag. 

Here is how the lineup looks when comparing price per ball:

Durability

Durability is something I never overlook. 

I put each ball through the wringer—literally—by using them across multiple rounds to see how well they held up.

The Srixon Q Star impressed me with its ability to maintain performance even after a few rough rounds. 

Meanwhile, the Callaway Supersoft held up well, but it’s a bit softer, so it might show wear slightly sooner. 

For me, a durable ball is one you can rely on to perform consistently, without worrying about scuffs and cuts after every shot.

Evaluate Forgiveness

Finally, I evaluated how forgiving each ball was on those less-than-perfect shots (because let’s be honest, we all have them—even if we pretend we don’t). 

The Callaway Supersoft is a champ here, offering a soft feel that helps cushion the blow of those occasional “what was I thinking?” swings. 

The Kirkland Urethane 3 Piece also showed impressive forgiveness, especially for its price—it’s like having a loyal friend who doesn’t judge you for slicing one into the trees. 

I’ve seen how a forgiving ball can do wonders for your confidence, letting you focus on the fun of the game rather than sweating the occasional mishit.

After all, golf’s tough enough without your ball making things harder!